Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan?

Alexx schrieb:

 > I shall be at 24th St & 7th Ave for two days. Unfortunately my host is
 > new and knows nothing about the city. On Monday he goes to work and I
 > need to be in Chicago by late afternoon. So, with 1/2 a day to kill,
 > I'd be more in a mood to spend time than money. I need to pick an
 > airport to fly out of.
 >
 > Although JFK is farther from Manhattan than is LGA, which one is
 > actually cheaper to get to? I'll have some luggage but can carry it
 > short distances.
 >
 > I assume that the train would make JFK cheaper to commute to, but I am
 > not sure. Is there public transportation to LGA?

with a cab: LGA is the cheapest
with public transportation: if you are uptown, there is a direct bus for
one metro ticket ride (1,66-2 USD). with the subway plus one bustrip you
can reach both LGA and JFK from Manhattan (transfers might be included
in ride for 1,66 or 2 USD). EWR can be reached by PATH-train (1,50) and
local NJT bus from Newark Pennstation. Shuttles, or taking LIRR/NJT and
airtrains will be more expensive to any of the 3 airports, between 10
and 15 USD.
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

Try these websites:

http://www.mta.info/nyct/service/airport.htm

http://www.panynj.gov/airtrain/

http://www.panynj.gov/airtrainnewark/
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

 >There is public transportation to LGA, it involves a bus connection at
 >LGA to the subway. For 24th and 7th, your best bet would be to take
 >the M-60 a few stops to the last stop in Queens which will also
 >connect you to the N and W trains. Take that train to Times Square,
 >transfer to the 1 or 9 to 23th St. You'll be one block away from your
 >destination. It will cost $2.

This is the right answer, except of course that it's backwards. Buy a
single-ride Metrocard for $2 available at all subway stations, then take
the 1 or 9 to Times Sq, then the N or W to Astoria Blvd, then the M60 bus
to the airport. If you don't like to change trains, you can take the 1
or 9 to 110th St and catch the M60 there, but it's faster to take the
subway to Queens.

I take this route all the time, and it's reasonably fast. At Astoria Blvd
there are signs in the station that direct you to the correct stairway to
go down to the place where the bus stops.
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

Alexx wrote:

 > I shall be at 24th St & 7th Ave for two days. Unfortunately my host is
 > new and knows nothing about the city. On Monday he goes to work and I
 > need to be in Chicago by late afternoon. So, with 1/2 a day to kill,
 > I'd be more in a mood to spend time than money. I need to pick an
 > airport to fly out of.
 >
 > Although JFK is farther from Manhattan than is LGA, which one is
 > actually cheaper to get to? I'll have some luggage but can carry it
 > short distances.
 >
 > I assume that the train would make JFK cheaper to commute to, but I am
 > not sure. Is there public transportation to LGA?

With public transit, there isn't much of a cost difference in getting to
the airport. There are other factors that should be considered such as
time and the airfares available for when you want to go to Chicago.
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

johnl DeleteThis @iecc.com (John R. Levine) wrote in message ...
  > >There is public transportation to LGA, it involves a bus connection at
  > >LGA to the subway. For 24th and 7th, your best bet would be to take
  > >the M-60 a few stops to the last stop in Queens which will also
  > >connect you to the N and W trains. Take that train to Times Square,
  > >transfer to the 1 or 9 to 23th St. You'll be one block away from your
  > >destination. It will cost $2.
 >
 > This is the right answer, except of course that it's backwards. Buy a
 > single-ride Metrocard for $2 available at all subway stations, then take
 > the 1 or 9 to Times Sq,

If so, aren't you already in Manhattan??? (I am looking at the
SUBJECT of this thread).


 > I take this route all the time, and it's reasonably fast.

Perhaps. I can only relate my experience going to Manhattan (Penn
Station, Grand Central Station or the Port Authorities on 42nd St.
Time Square) from Newark to the same a friend of mine took from LGA.

The shuttle bus from the EWR airport takes about 30 minutes (even in
rush hours) to get to Time Sq. I have taken that bus many times.
$9.50 each way, and about half of that for Seniors (65 or above).

A friend of mine took over 3 hours to get from LGA to a Hilton
hotel in Mahattan (not far from Time Sq) and missed a bridge
tournament date he had with me. Neither the tournament director
nor I tought it possible for one whose flight arrival was more
than 3.5 hours from starting time to miss it, but he did.

Taking a taxi may be the SLOWEST way to get anywhere in Manhattan.
My friend was taking one of the SuperShuttles from LGA, I think.

Based on that single comparison, I suspect EWR beats LGA hands down,
in cost and travel time, to get from the airport to Manhatten (central,
near Time Sq. anyway).

-- Bob.
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

On Thu, 05 Aug 2004 06:35:30 GMT, DorothyknowsDallas
wrote:

 >Alexx wrote:
 >
  >> I shall be at 24th St & 7th Ave for two days. Unfortunately my host is
  >> new and knows nothing about the city. On Monday he goes to work and I
  >> need to be in Chicago by late afternoon. So, with 1/2 a day to kill,
  >> I'd be more in a mood to spend time than money. I need to pick an
  >> airport to fly out of.
  >>
  >> Although JFK is farther from Manhattan than is LGA, which one is
  >> actually cheaper to get to? I'll have some luggage but can carry it
  >> short distances.
  >>
  >> I assume that the train would make JFK cheaper to commute to, but I am
  >> not sure. Is there public transportation to LGA?
 >
 >With public transit, there isn't much of a cost difference in getting to
 >the airport. There are other factors that should be considered such as
 >time and the airfares available for when you want to go to Chicago.

The cost is the same, but JFK is much farther from Manhattan business
destinations. Also, the commute from JFK via mass transit is
considerably longer.
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

Reef Fish wrote:
 > A friend of mine took over 3 hours to get from LGA to a Hilton
 > hotel in Mahattan (not far from Time Sq) and missed a bridge
 > tournament date he had with me. Neither the tournament director
 > nor I tought it possible for one whose flight arrival was more
 > than 3.5 hours from starting time to miss it, but he did.

When you are going to/from LGA during peak commute hours you really have to
take the subway for as much of the trip as possible of you'll waste a lot of
time. Take a bus/taxi from the airport to the train and ride that the rest
of the way.

miguel
--
Hit The Road! Photos and tales from around the world: <a rel="nofollow" style='text-decoration: none;' href="http://travel.u.nu" target="_blank">http://travel.u.nu</a>
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

Miguel Cruz wrote:
 >

  > > A friend of mine took over 3 hours to get from LGA to a Hilton
  > > hotel in Mahattan (not far from Time Sq) and missed a bridge
  > > tournament date he had with me. Neither the tournament director
  > > nor I tought it possible for one whose flight arrival was more
  > > than 3.5 hours from starting time to miss it, but he did.
 >
 > When you are going to/from LGA during peak commute hours you really have to
 > take the subway for as much of the trip as possible of you'll waste a lot of
 > time. Take a bus/taxi from the airport to the train and ride that the rest
 > of the way.

Perhaps I was just lucky, then - I've twice taken a taxi to LGA from Lincoln Center at what I assume
would be peak commute hours - between 5.30pm and 6pm - and both times it's only taken 30 minutes or
so (once via the 59th Street bridge, once via the Triborough - it didn't seem to make a lot of
difference).

--
Stephen


CORDELIA: I personally don't think it's possible to come up with a crazier plan.
OZ: We attack the Mayor with hummus.
CORDELIA: I stand corrected.
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

Stephen Farrow wrote:
 > Miguel Cruz wrote:
  >> When you are going to/from LGA during peak commute hours you really have
  >> to take the subway for as much of the trip as possible of you'll waste a
  >> lot of time. Take a bus/taxi from the airport to the train and ride that
  >> the rest of the way.
 >
 > Perhaps I was just lucky, then - I've twice taken a taxi to LGA from
 > Lincoln Center at what I assume would be peak commute hours - between
 > 5.30pm and 6pm - and both times it's only taken 30 minutes or so (once via
 > the 59th Street bridge, once via the Triborough - it didn't seem to make a
 > lot of difference).

I'm surprised. I've sat in traffic on Manhattan for that long.

miguel
--
Hit The Road! Photos and tales from around the world: <a rel="nofollow" style='text-decoration: none;' href="http://travel.u.nu" target="_blank">http://travel.u.nu</a>
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

Miguel Cruz wrote:
 >

  > > Miguel Cruz wrote:
   > >> When you are going to/from LGA during peak commute hours you really have
   > >> to take the subway for as much of the trip as possible of you'll waste a
   > >> lot of time. Take a bus/taxi from the airport to the train and ride that
   > >> the rest of the way.
  > >
  > > Perhaps I was just lucky, then - I've twice taken a taxi to LGA from
  > > Lincoln Center at what I assume would be peak commute hours - between
  > > 5.30pm and 6pm - and both times it's only taken 30 minutes or so (once via
  > > the 59th Street bridge, once via the Triborough - it didn't seem to make a
  > > lot of difference).
 >
 > I'm surprised. I've sat in traffic on Manhattan for that long.

I was surprised as well - the first time, at least - particularly given that, yes, I've sat in
traffic for what felt like *forever* in the NYC rush hour on more than one occasion (the worst being
a memorably hideous bus trip from Newark Airport into Manhattan that was held up by some kind of
accident on the approach to the Lincoln Tunnel). As I said, maybe I was just lucky - and I certainly
wouldn't suggest anyone leave just 30 minutes to get to LGA from Lincoln Center at any time of day,
never mind rush hour (on both occasions I was expecting it to take longer; I was aiming for 8pm
flights, but with just a carry-on).

--
Stephen


Dracula, shmacula.
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan? 

Miguel Cruz wrote in message ...

  > > Miguel Cruz wrote:
   > >> When you are going to/from LGA during peak commute hours you really have
   > >> to take the subway for as much of the trip as possible of you'll waste a
   > >> lot of time. Take a bus/taxi from the airport to the train and ride that
   > >> the rest of the way.
  > >
  > > Perhaps I was just lucky, then - I've twice taken a taxi to LGA from
  > > Lincoln Center at what I assume would be peak commute hours - between
  > > 5.30pm and 6pm - and both times it's only taken 30 minutes or so (once via
  > > the 59th Street bridge, once via the Triborough - it didn't seem to make a
  > > lot of difference).
 >
 > I'm surprised. I've sat in traffic on Manhattan for that long.

I haven't, but I have, many times, taken a cab for only a few blocks
in Manhattan near Time Sq., and each time watched the pedestrians walk
faster than the cab could go!

The cabbie said that is COMMON.

-- Bob.
 >> Stay informed about: Which NYC airport is cheaper to get to from Manhattan?